Elder Westin Juarez and I served as missionaries together for six weeks in Pagosa Springs, CO. Though we had some disappointments, we saw success from our efforts in that area, and we both had a love for music. Even after we were reassigned to new areas and new companions, we would see each other occasionally at missionary conferences. He knew I composed music, and he would joke around by asking, “So Elder Totten, when are you going to write me a song?” I knew he wasn’t serious, but then I thought, why not?
I knew one of his favorite songs was “Come, Thou Fount of Ever Blessing.” I’ve heard him sing it very well when we were companions. I decided to write a new tune for that hymn. I came up with a melody that was inspired by the melody of an LDS song for youth, titled “Strength Beyond My Own.” When I had access to a piano in those rare moments of free time, I came up with a simple piano part based on a simple chord progression. I wrote it as a hymn tune. I even treated it as a hymn tune by giving it a name: Juarez. I sent the music (written on a piece of notebook paper) to Elder Juarez, telling him he finally has his song. He never mentioned the song in later interactions, but I suppose he didn’t have to. I wanted the experience of writing a hymn tune and I dedicated it to Elder Juarez simply because he (jokingly) asked for it.